Intrinsic value vs price, and the three families of valuation models
KnownMemorizeThe verdict rule
| Estimate vs price | Verdict | Action |
|---|---|---|
| V > P | undervalued | buy candidate |
| V = P (or P inside the error band) | fairly valued | no action |
| V < P | overvalued | avoid or sell |
Memory hook Value is what you get, price is what you pay. If you get more than you pay, it is cheap.
Know it cold Act only when the gap beats your model uncertainty AND price is expected to converge to value in your horizon.
MemorizeWhich family fits which company
| Family | Best fit | Main weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Present value | mature dividend payer; stable, forecastable cash flows | very sensitive to r and g; needs long forecasts |
| Multiplier | company with listed, similar peers | relative only; accounting differences; negative earnings |
| Asset-based | bank, investment holding firm, liquidation, private firm with few intangibles | intangibles and specialized assets are hard to value |
Memory hook Cash flows, peers, or assets: ask which of the three you can measure most reliably for this company.
Know it cold A multiple tells you cheap or dear compared with peers, never cheap or dear in absolute terms.
Key terms
- intrinsic value Use it
- market price Know the idea
- undervalued Memorize
- overvalued Memorize
- fairly valued Memorize
- present value models Use it
- discounted cash flow models Know the idea
- multiplier models Use it
- market multiple models Know the idea
- asset-based valuation models Use it
- Undervalued Memorize V above P; a candidate to buy
- Fairly valued Memorize V equals P, or P sits inside your error band
- Overvalued Memorize V below P; avoid, sell or short
- Present value (discounted cash flow) Use it PV of cash flows to shareholders
- Dividend discount model cash flow is dividends
- Free-cash-flow-to-equity model cash flow is dividend-paying capacity
-
- Multiplier (market multiple) Use it a multiple of a fundamental
- Price multiples P/E, P/B, P/S, P/CF
- Enterprise value multiples EV/EBITDA, EV/sales
-
- Asset-based Use it fair value of assets minus liabilities
Formulas
Quick example
An analyst values a share at 30.00 and it trades at 33.60. 30.00 ÷ 33.60 − 1 = −10.71%, so the share looks overvalued.
- 30÷33.6−1= −0.1071
- 30ENTER33.6÷1− −0.1071
ENTER enter (on the HP, puts the number on the stack)